The Hidden Risks of Bonds: Safety Isn’t Always What It Seems

Chart comparing US CPI inflation with price changes of AGG and TLT bond ETFs from 2022 to 2026

As long as I can remember, investors have been told that bonds are “safe.” But history tells a much different story. Bonds have risks that many investors may not be aware of. Let’s go.

Consider the iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG), a widely used benchmark for investment-grade U.S. bonds. Over the past five years, its performance has been disappointing (to say the least), its price is actually down, while the Consumer Price Index (CPI) has risen more than 21%. Meaning: Cost of living has gone up while “so called safe bonds” have gone down in value. A double whammy.

An investment that doesn’t grow while the cost-of-living rises isn’t preserving wealth. It’s losing it.

Understanding bond risks is essential:

  • Interest Rate Risk: Bond prices and interest rates move in opposite directions. When rates rise, bond prices fall. As an example, when interest rates rose in 2022, the overall bond index dropped more than -19.5%, and TLT (which tracks long-term Treasury bonds) was down more than -50%! What may be hard to believe, but Investors who purchased TLT are still down more than -43%. Bonds can and do lose value. Interest rate is real.
  • Credit Risk: Bonds are essentially loans to governments or corporations. If an issuer experiences financial difficulties, missed interest payments, credit downgrades, or even default, bond prices are affected. This happens.
  • Reinvestment Risk: When bonds mature or pay interest, investors must reinvest that money at prevailing rates. If interest rates have declined, future income may be considerably lower.
  • Inflation Risk: Perhaps the most overlooked risk is the gradual erosion of purchasing power. Even when bonds generate positive nominal returns, those returns can be negative after accounting for inflation.

Investors should never conflate the perception of safety with the reality of owning bonds and bond funds.

The reality is more nuanced. It depends. Owning the right type of bond, at the right time, can be a safe investment. While owning the wrong type of bond, at the wrong time, can be disastrous.

Not all bonds are created equal. Know what you own and why.

-Paul R. Rossi, CFA